I, for one, think we should eliminate the ANSWERS thread entirely. Why should there be a thread where the answers to the Listener exist? The answers are posted by the Times eventually. Up until recently this site was just a place to go to ask for and receive nudges. At least one poster was banned for blurting out answers that were not requested.
Given the name of the thread, it's perfectly reasonable for plouty or anyone else to think that they can just ask for an answer or give the answer when all that was requested was a nudge. It's reasonable, but I don't think that's what the community as a whole wants to see. As long as there's an ANSWERS thread there is going to be unpleasantness between those who do not want to see answers revealed and those who reasonably expect they can come here to get or give answers.
In addition, in spite of the preamble at the start of the thread, it's clear that people are giving away a lot of the theme here. The only answers that are supposed to be discussed here are answers to clues. All this talk of TTC (and an additional TTC!) and what to do with the R and what goes in the extra cell has nothing to do with CLUE answers.
At some point those of us who come here mainly to be helpful but object to too much info being revealed are just going to abandon the site. Then those who need a nudge won't have anyone to get help from.