I don’t wish to rehearse the old arguments that have been aired many times on this, Ploughty, even if they are new to you. Many people would prefer that no answers are given at all, as is the case on Answerbank. There is, after all, a yearly competition for all-correct Listener solvers. Folk start the puzzle and solve it at very different times and speeds, and if they come here seeking gentle hints, have their enjoyment ruined, because it’s impossible to unsee things. So in my view it’s a matter of courtesy to them to give only hints, and avoid giving the game away unnecessarily. But I agree the thread title is unhelpful in that regard