Jordan, the information, reminder, about giving the clue (and any pertinent information) was just to increase your chances of getting help. Forum members do lots of crosswords, but not everyone does ALL the puzzles. I, for example, seldom do the Guardian or Observer crosswords, and I like it when a clue from there appears on the Forum. It's good to get the chance to tackle 'other' puzzles, but seeing the clue is ... vital for that.