CancelReport This Post

Please fill out the form below with your name, e-mail address and the reason(s) you wish to report this post.

 

Crossword Help Forum
Forum Rules

ukridge

27th July 2020, 17:01
Having solved 30 and 26 I see there's no indication of what the extra letter is in the first cell of 22. Does that become clear in the endgame?
101 of 143  -   Report This Post

unclued

27th July 2020, 17:24
Yes ukridge you are right. The letter you want is Z.
102 of 143  -   Report This Post

merenz

27th July 2020, 18:20
Post at 103 reported as spam
103 of 143  -   Report This Post

durban

27th July 2020, 18:48
Is there a verb "to smatter"? Must look it up, I suppose, but life is short and getting shorter, as Sabre here demonstrates. Anyway, my relevant smattering is not letting me get much sense of the right-hand column, except for its first cell. Anyone else as puzzled?
104 of 143  -   Report This Post

rad

27th July 2020, 23:31
Like several other posters I am in awe of those who managed to solve this monster unaided, and I would have given up but for their helpful hints. Thanks to all concerned.

I have just cracked the code and acknowledge that it is stupendously brilliant. I can now see why the grid had to have so many complications and unfamiliar combinations of letters to make it work. But surely that doesn’t justify the obscurities deliberately introduced into the clues.

I’ve forgotten who said and in which thread that an obscure answer should not be clued by means of another obscure word. This should be an established principle for all setters and editors, in my opinion. Obscure answer, straightforward clue. Call it the Principle of Compensation if you like.

And what goes for individual clues goes for the puzzle as a whole. A complex theme, such as this one, should have accessible clues, so that a good proportion of solvers can get to grips with it. We should not have people saying that they have not enjoyed their efforts at solving crosswords. What are they for?!
105 of 143  -   Report This Post

suzannahj

28th July 2020, 18:12
Back to earth with a bump this week, after two successful full completions. That'll teach me for being too pleased with myself!

A hint on 22 down would be welcome, as would knowing where the extra letter goes in 15 across. I have quite a few answers, but almost nothing in the grid thanks to the added and omitted letters. 15 across would be a big help.

Oh, and 39 down... Am I looking for an artist whose name starts with E and ends with T? I know one, but he doesn't seem to fit with the rest of the clue.
106 of 143  -   Report This Post

unclued

28th July 2020, 18:55
Susannah, the playing piece In 39dn is MAN. 15ac the extra letter is the fourth one.
107 of 143  -   Report This Post

unclued

28th July 2020, 18:58
In 22dn the teacher is RAV and Newcastle is extra.
108 of 143  -   Report This Post

suzannahj

28th July 2020, 19:04
Thanks, unclued. I'm kicking myself about the artist now.

And a bigger thanks for 'rav', as I would NEVER have got that.
109 of 143  -   Report This Post

grunos

28th July 2020, 20:48
Wow. Finally finished. Unbelievable puzzle. Unbelievable piece of setting and unbelievable piece of solving by anyone who managed it without reading this blog! Thanks to all for the hints and tips
110 of 143  -   Report This Post