CancelReport This Post

Please fill out the form below with your name, e-mail address and the reason(s) you wish to report this post.

 

Crossword Help Forum
Forum Rules

brendan

30th September 2023, 22:46
I think you're probably right Biffo:-)
141 of 179  -   Report This Post

rogissimo

30th September 2023, 22:59
I’m glad you think so too, biffo, as that was my immediate thought right at the top of the thread. However it’s interesting that Boatman has apparently mentioned the error in 25a (see jono, many posts back), but hasn’t as far as I’m aware said anything about the absence of a special instruction. So perhaps he did intend us to work it out for ourselves. I agree though: I think it would be a first.
Perhaps jono can elicit something from Boatman?
142 of 179  -   Report This Post

jono

30th September 2023, 23:15
Rogissimo, see my post @89 the second part of which covers the special instruction point. Perhaps it was an editorial mix up, perhaps not. Either way we all seem to have solved the puzzle which is surely good!
In other news, only 45 mins to Everyman 😃
143 of 179  -   Report This Post

rogissimo

30th September 2023, 23:22
Sorry I missed that brilliant comment from Boatman, jono - juggling too much today clearly. Thank you! And I’ve certainly drawn my conclusion…
144 of 179  -   Report This Post

rogissimo

30th September 2023, 23:23
And yes, deliberate or not on the part of Boatman, I ended up enjoying the additional challenge.
145 of 179  -   Report This Post

geeker

1st October 2023, 00:15
Regarding Boatman@89's comment on preamble,

“I can neither confirm nor deny ... It'll be interesting to see how many people preferred it that way!”

It's really difficult to say! A posteriori, having solved the puzzle I prefer it w/o preamble.

But if 21 hours ago while I was struggling, one queried me about a possibly missing preamble, I'd have preferred one!

As a dedicated second guesser / Monday morning quarterback etc. I'll stick with the posterior decision. 🤣
146 of 179  -   Report This Post

jazzgirl

1st October 2023, 07:22

minno

1st October 2023, 12:19
Further to my previous. This was an Easter egg hunt without being informed that it was Easter.
148 of 179  -   Report This Post

pault

1st October 2023, 13:05
60s? I saw them in 1993, daughter saw them this year (plenty of personnel changes along the way. Also, if you don't know the band but do know agricultural history,... 😁
149 of 179  -   Report This Post

dhope

1st October 2023, 13:13
My younger son is here from Australia so didn’t start until this morning , what an exciting forum! Have finished ,had got 18 and 21 before I looked at forum so was not aware of theme. I did consult list of …….. , I have no problem with that ,all part of the puzzle solving and learning process. A very clever and tricky crossword ,certainly consider it an achievement to have completed it with help from you guys of course. Thanks to Boatman and the forum best wishes to all.

Post amended by Admin to remove a word
150 of 179  -   Report This Post