Hello Doglet
Bairstow has failed as a Test batsman once already but, if Balance had to be dropped, then he is the man in form at present.
This decision will have maintained the Yorkshire balance (sorry!) in the side which, as a southerner, I find a little difficult to take!
Cook, I think, suffers from only ever being a cricketer (and a very good one) but I think this restricts his ability to think 'outside the box'. I also wonder who, of the current side, could take over and retain Cook in the team. Root is not ready yet, despite what M Vaughan and other Yorkshire commentators say!
Where is another Mike Brearley when you need one?