Thanks for the clarification Prospero. I am still of the opinion that an &lit doesn't require a def and that if there is a def it should be at the beginning or end of the clue.
I also think a good clue should be a clear set of instructions leading to the solution. You shouldn't be required to perform retrosoective linguistic and verbal contortions to fit asolution to the clue however obvious it might be. My acid test is whether the clue can be solved without half the letters being provided by crossers.