Dorrien, this is what happened when I asked ChatGPT to judge the clues…
My question..
“Here are the top 3 clues from a crossword clue setting competition. Please judge which one is best and say why…
Suggestion to take knight after second pawn advanced (5)
Odds a great horse might shine (7)
They may be lively and likely on the radio (6)”
ChatGPTs answer…
“As an AI language model, I don't have personal preferences, but I can provide an objective analysis of the three crossword clues based on their effectiveness in conveying the intended answer.
"Suggestion to take knight after second pawn advanced (5)"
This is a well-crafted clue that effectively uses wordplay to lead the solver to the answer. The phrase "take knight" suggests the chess move, while "pawn advanced" implies that the solver should look for a word that means "advanced." The answer to the clue is "HINTS," which fits the criteria provided in the clue. Overall, this is a strong clue that challenges the solver and provides a satisfying "aha" moment when the solution is discovered.
"Odds a great horse might shine (7)"
This clue uses a clever play on words to lead the solver to the answer. The phrase "great horse" suggests a thoroughbred or other highly regarded equine, while "shine" implies that the solver should look for a word that means "succeed." The answer to the clue is "OUTCOME," which fits the criteria provided in the clue. This is a good clue that requires the solver to think creatively and outside the box.
"They may be lively and likely on the radio (6)"
This clue is more straightforward than the other two and relies more on definition than wordplay. The phrase "lively and likely" implies that the solver should look for a word that means "probable" or "expected," while the mention of the radio suggests that the answer is a type of audio broadcast. The answer to the clue is "VOICES," which fits the criteria provided in the clue. This is a decent clue that provides a clear path to the solution, but it is not as engaging or challenging as the other two.
In summary, all three clues have their strengths and weaknesses, but I believe the first clue, "Suggestion to take knight after second pawn advanced (5)," is the best because it effectively combines wordplay and definition to create an engaging and challenging clue that rewards the solver's efforts.”
Well done Buddy! You are the AI favourite. No prize, sorry :-)