CancelReport This Post

Please fill out the form below with your name, e-mail address and the reason(s) you wish to report this post.

 

Crossword Help Forum
Forum Rules

planks

18th May 2024, 15:42
As this week's Listener was a numbers one, I went back to this one. OMG, what an amazing puzzle! I wouldn't have finished it without the 'Easter egg' nudge. Thank you.
121 of 126  -   Report This Post

mooncow

19th May 2024, 04:18
This was a very fine puzzle, and very satisfying. What I like with Sabre is that although you often have to work hard for the clues -- and sometimes it takes me quite a while to figure out each clue even *after* I have the correct answer... -- once you do figure it out you can be absolutely sure you have the right answer!

I do agree though that the phrase was VERY hard to find from scant clues. I'm not sure what could have been done to make that slightly more tractable. People have mentioned ODQ -- but when I assembled my letter pairs, I found one distinctive word (which turned out to be the first of the four words), but that word does NOT link to the relevant quotation in my (1996) edition of ODQ, though it seems like it really should so maybe that was a glitch that was fixed in later editions :-/ I didn't recognise the words, but the next thing I built from my letter pairs was an unlikely-looking bunch of possibilities one of which caused Google to spring into life (it turned out to be the second of the four words). And suddenly all became clear. But without Google I'd never have got there. The vague link in one clue is hardly an additional hint -- jeg's hint was better! although in my case I only understood even that AFTER I'd solved it all... :-)

Many thanks Sabre! Now, a nice numeric to take away on holiday with me...!
122 of 126  -   Report This Post

grunos

21st May 2024, 20:33
YES! Finished at last after a week and a half! That was very tricky but all the more satisfying to finally finish. If anyone is still reading this thread after all this time thanks for the subtle hints to the theme. Wouldn’t have got it in a month of Sundays without.
123 of 126  -   Report This Post

grunos

21st May 2024, 20:34
And why was nobody asking about 33a? That was my LOI!
124 of 126  -   Report This Post

rhsl

21st May 2024, 22:39
LOI?
125 of 126  -   Report This Post

grunos

23rd May 2024, 12:00
Last one in. Last clue solved. Obvious now but I just couldn’t see it
126 of 126  -   Report This Post