CancelReport This Post

Please fill out the form below with your name, e-mail address and the reason(s) you wish to report this post.

 

Crossword Help Forum
Forum Rules

wintonian

6th May 2018, 10:23
Hi, Demeter,

I wasn’t really satisfied with the clue to 1dn, because the word hinted at for “old horse-keeper” doesn’t appear in either of my editions of TCD. Arguably, it’s a standard compound form, though, that turns a place where a horse may be kept into the agent who puts the horse there.

The misprint is the second letter of “mare”. Think of an “old chestnut”.
31 of 139  -   Report This Post

demeter

6th May 2018, 10:28
Thanks Wintonian. All clear
32 of 139  -   Report This Post

wintonian

6th May 2018, 10:29
Hi, Demeter.

In fact, I’ve misparsed 1dn. I was thinking of a place where a single horse might be kept, but I should have been thinking of a building where several horses might be kept. There is a noun derivative from this word, described by TCD as “Scot or archaic”, that can lose its fourth letter to give the answer to 1dn.
33 of 139  -   Report This Post

woodlouse

6th May 2018, 10:32
Cockie

I didn't mention my Maths degree, having been bitten in the derriere by doing so on other occasions.

I am pretty sure that 14d is O-level additional maths.

Given that the complex components of the solutions are surds, reasonable accuracy is satisfied by rounding them to 2 sig fig.

The real component does not require such a compromise.

Counting in whole numbers from the x-axis leaves you on a line.

Counting an odd number of halves from the y=axis leaves you in the centre of the square.
34 of 139  -   Report This Post

demeter

6th May 2018, 10:52
Wintonian, actually that Scot/arch term is what I thought you were referring to in your first post.
35 of 139  -   Report This Post

murky

6th May 2018, 10:56
So far this puzzle hasn't appealed to me at all. There are some very annoying ambiguities in the misprints (eg 7a) making it difficult to get a coherent message. Some of the corrected definitions are dubious (35a?) or very, very loose, and in at least one case a regional indicator is lacking. The grammatical synonymity in 48a is dubious. I know definition misprints can present a challenge for a setter but some of these seem to border on the unfair.

Then there's the mathematical element. It's 60 years since I solved quadratic equations at school, and so far this one has defeated me.

I assume the last word 9d is the misprinted word but I can't find any word to fit my letters and the assumed definitions.
36 of 139  -   Report This Post

woodlouse

6th May 2018, 11:06
Don't give up Murky

9d -helps to have had a misspent youth.

Its an anglicisation of Riz La(croix)

Also the answer is not in the setter's own anagram resource.

There is at least one good quadratic-solver online.
37 of 139  -   Report This Post

murky

6th May 2018, 13:41
Thanks, Woodlouse. I was fairly sure of the wordplay but my anagram solver didn't produce an answer that fitted, and the word isn't in the Chambers I was using (which isn't the most recent).

The only sensible solution to the quadratic that I have found is in the form of a parabola, but I have no idea how it should be represented or modified in the light of 14d.




38 of 139  -   Report This Post

woodlouse

6th May 2018, 14:15
OK Murky I think we are past the spoiler threshhold.

Loaf > leaf

There are no real solutions because the parabola does not intersect the x axis (y=0)

the solution is x= -3 1/2 +/- 6.089i

The Argand diagram (which is NOT the same grid as that on which the parabola is represented) represents complex numbers in cartesian form with the real numbers on the x (horizontal) axis and the imaginary numbers on the y axis. On our grid those are the apparently unnecessary thick lines dividing it into 4.

each X is already 3 1/2 squares from the y axis

at the moment they are at - 6.5 and + 6.5 on the y axis

A vertical shift of each X already in the grid so that it straddles the boundary of the empty square is 'reasonably' accurate
39 of 139  -   Report This Post

woodlouse

6th May 2018, 14:17
The penultimate paragraph should indicate that the locations of the Xs are level with those points +/- 6.5 on the y axis, not on it.
40 of 139  -   Report This Post