Syzzie: You really got my hopes up. I subscribe to The Atlantic, both online and hardcopy, and I thought I might have been missing something all these years by not looking for the Puzzler in the online edition. In 2005 there was an announcement about the setters' retirement, but you posted a puzzle from 2008, which I certainly never saw. I logged in and keyed in "puzzler", and what came up was the archive I posted above. Very mysterious. Where did the 2008 puzzle come from? I do recall that for some time it was only available online; even that was a disappointment.
Kiwikid: I clearly remember having the same experience with ODOUR! One of those epiphanies that cause you to whack your forehead.