Ixion,
I'm not having a go at you personally. I just think that if people can get answers without giving the clue,etc they will never see any reason to provide same.
Someone like FredaB wants to help,asks for the necessary info but then a third party provides the answer anyway. This must annoy FredaB.
I know you were just being helpful Ixion but I think it would be better to encourage posters give the clue,etc as a matter of routine.and not help if they don't.