We have 16 excellent clues, submitted by 8 entrants, and some nifty comments – mostly by Paul, all of which we enjoyed – especially the banter! Fewer entries than normal, to be expected perhaps as it was quite a tricky word to clue, but the stalwarts have come through with some fantastic submissions, so thank you all.
We judged each clue using the usual criteria – good surface reading, the definition was met, how the clueing mechanism was used and, in this case, although not essential, a bonus if the injunction to attempt a rhyme was also attempted.
We liked the simplicity of Jono’s swift response@2 – beating Chrise to be the first out of the gate, although Chrise didn’t appear this time.
Paul’s @4 and @7 amused us. We liked Amej’s @10 and Geeker’s @21 straightforward anagrams, also Tyke’s @11 use of a double anagram and Geeker’s @16 both with the rhyming bonus.
But for sheer poetic ingenuity, doggedness – plus the stuffed brown envelope that arrived -
We both agreed that Jono’s submission @22 should win the prize this week:
Tolkien’s beast returns to overcome evil Mab and clinch Cynghanedd.
Well done Jono.
Hope you all enjoy some of the attached doggerel and music.
https://youtu.be/wezbEBxA6X4?si=-CxE0ZyKbiOOU688
https://youtu.be/XUsdhwgCvw4?si=wMlUeKvDqGjgAdbq
https://youtu.be/OMf4P89XlCg?si=Fj3011WiCeZcolFJ
https://youtu.be/N16Fdx9Z9Ik?si=yr4kv-FaI-zRGueJ
https://youtu.be/PSduHd4NchM?si=TGshM-H9-1hdvAeo