CancelReport This Post

Please fill out the form below with your name, e-mail address and the reason(s) you wish to report this post.

 

Crossword Help Forum
Forum Rules

buddy

18th May 2022, 20:10
With PR well underway, I think we can wrap this up an hour early:

In contrast to most weeks when we have variety of clues from a number of different setters, this week we have a number of different clues from a variety of setters. However the difficulty of picking a winner remains constant. Plus ça change!

As always, I'm looking for that elusive combination of clever wordplay and smooth-as-Sam-Cooke surface.

Honorable mentions to tyke@4 and patrich@25 for nice acrostics; mattrom@15, mprs@14 and simon@8 for deft double-defs; chris@2, mprs@29 and aristo@38 for nice charades; and jono@3 for the compound anagram.

As for the grand prize, I debated among these four, and as always had to find nit-picky reasons to prefer one over any of the others:

geeker@19, useby@21, jono@23, mattrom@36.

geeker@19, I was impressed that you could find a way to hide the word, but ultimately decided that "collectibles" implies something more valuable than just "stuff" (as I said, I needed to get picky. And, sorry spike but geeker got there first.)

useby@21, love the surface, but that required the word "TO" which I think doesn't quite work for the wordplay.

That leaves jono@23 vs mattrom@36. Both have excellent wordplay, but in the end the winner has a surface that's just too good, and gets an extra point for brevity. So sorry jono@23, but the gold goes to mattrom@36:

French francs (old notes) rejected as money (5)

Congrats to mattrom and thanks to everyone for taking part.

Prizes:

Too much stuff:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MvgN5gCuLac

The Right Stuff:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LQt579381OI

Big Stuff:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ooYExfw9lLY

Just Stuff:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7V-DguG1RiI
41 of 55  -   Report This Post

simplesimon

18th May 2022, 20:25

Congratulations Mattrom again!

Thanks Buddy for hosting.
42 of 55  -   Report This Post

tyke51

18th May 2022, 20:32
Well done Mattrom - thanks Buddy.
43 of 55  -   Report This Post

spike2

18th May 2022, 20:33
Well done, Mattrom. Thanks Buddy.

@Geeker I hadn't looked at other clues, otherwise I wouldn't have used Uffizi. I liked your clue.
44 of 55  -   Report This Post

jono

18th May 2022, 20:59
Congrats Mattrom, well deserved. Many thanks Buddy, good challenge, agree with your adjudication. Enjoyed that last clip.

[Incidentally, on the subject of compound anagrams, I thought the one by Crucible in today’s Guardian was particularly good]
45 of 55  -   Report This Post

buddy

18th May 2022, 21:09
jono - I did notice that from Crucible today. I have been on the lookout for a good one that doesn't use "this xxx" as the definition but that seems to be the standard format.
46 of 55  -   Report This Post

mathprofrockstar

18th May 2022, 21:15
Congrats, mattrom. Thanks for hosting buddy, and for the mentions.
47 of 55  -   Report This Post

aristophanes

18th May 2022, 21:27
Lovely as usual, mattrom. Thanks for the mention, buddy.
48 of 55  -   Report This Post

patrich

18th May 2022, 21:37
Congratulations mattrom, another lovely clue. Thanks buddy, a good contest and some fun clips.
49 of 55  -   Report This Post

geeker

18th May 2022, 21:57
Congratulations, mattrom! Thanks to buddy for hosting, shortlisting and clips. I wanted to compose a clue based on the band of clip #4, but failed.

spike2: Thanks, no problem, I assumed you posted w/o reading other clues. Since I enter so many no-hopers, the occasional inadvertent duplicate is actually a confidence booster. 🤣
50 of 55  -   Report This Post