CancelReport This Post

Please fill out the form below with your name, e-mail address and the reason(s) you wish to report this post.

 

Crossword Help Forum
Forum Rules

jono

6th January 2021, 18:21
Ok here we go. Great creativity as always and a pleasure to judge.
There were 17 setters with 36 clues. I counted 6 straight anagrams, 4 subtractive and 1 ghost, 15 constructions, 7 double definitions, 2 literary definitions (I’m counting Mathprof’s entry even though he was pipped to the post by Jimmy) and 1 Spoonerism.

All four of the main definitions were covered with 12 blunders, 11 pieces of underwear, 7 flowers, 5 loaves of bread and 1 florid letter (thanks to Buddy!).

Good to see some new names - welcome Heathcliff and Sheep, not sure if this is the first time you’ve entered or if you are returning old hands, either way great to have you.

Some ingenious subtractive anagrams, I particularly liked Fiery’s (sweets ballroom - was let)* and Marty’s (Boris met older - tired)*

Mattrom’s "moo blurs" Spoonerism was a delight and Mattrom also takes top place for most indicated DBEs of plants with Cowslips and Acacias (I thought there would be more of those).

Some smart devices were Jimmy’s “Nice view” (of the French sea), Mattrom’s cleverly hidden anagrind in “short-changed” and PaulH’s “deposit”.

Also some well disguised definitions stood out from Paul (smalls), Chris (boobs), Aristo (beachwear), Fiery (oops) and Dorrien (red faces).
Tyke@24 entertained with a poem without a clue, and Buddy's basketball based clue @28 would work brilliantly stateside I think.
Jimmy and Mathprof win the prize for best (only) literary reference (see below).
PaulH’s entry @17 reminded me of one of the opening sequences to Fawlty Towers where the signage is altered to “Flowery .....” (I’ll leave you to Google that one ;-)

Which brings us to the subject of kangaroos, boomers, euros and old men. Who knew, well you all did, not me seemingly. Thanks for the education from Faiton, PeterM and Mattrom.

So to the top three…

Bronze
PeterM@26
Old men wearing large, baggy knickers (8)
Had it not been for Peter’s clarification I would have read old men as baby boomers and still be satisfied, but the kangaroo definition is a treat.

Silver
Mattrom@29
Over-large jumpers worn down under? (8)
More kangaroos and trademark cleverness from Mattrom with a suitably antipodean surface read!

[Btw I’m also surprised Chambers doesn’t give L for large. It is given in both Collins and the ODE which seems perfectly fair. Not the OED however (though I did just discover from the OED that in a ship’s logbook L may stand for lightening… I digress)]

Gold
KT17@7

Crusty ones born in the sixties - around fifty (8)

I really liked this, a play on "crusty ones”, nice surface and even the maths works (give or take)! I dare say it’s also a fairly good description of a few forum members (I include myself!) ;-)

Congrats KT, here is your prize…
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I8W4LyIXINE

And inspired by Jimmy and Mathprof, here’s the bonus prize…
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X7FobPxu27M&t=29s
51 of 65  -   Report This Post

tyke51

6th January 2021, 19:00
Well done KT17 - a worthy winner in a high class competition - Thanks for a good word Jono and your excellent summing up - the clips were good too - don`t think I`m ready to tackle Ulysses just yet!
52 of 65  -   Report This Post

chrise

6th January 2021, 19:15
Congrats KT17 - nice clue.
Thanks for all your work, jono. I can't stand cacti. Unfortunately my daughter is a keen grower of cacti and succulents. I particularly don't like the ones on the kitchen windowsills that attack me when I pull the blinds down! (It's not just cacti - anything with prickles. Hand-weeding in a garden in which holly is grown is not a pleasure....)
53 of 65  -   Report This Post

kt17

6th January 2021, 19:16
Thank you Jono - what a pleasant surprise... I must say that the quality of these competitions' entries has risen to a point where most weeks I don't feel up to it, but I'm not complaining!

The prize was a delight to behold!

Thanks again and see you next week,

M
54 of 65  -   Report This Post

paulhabershon

6th January 2021, 19:19
Congratulations, Kt17, and thanks for the mentions, Jono, in your detailed summary.

As I prepare to launch Peer Review 470 I realise nervously that some recent debriefs, like jono's today, are becoming rather hard acts to follow!
55 of 65  -   Report This Post

peterm

6th January 2021, 19:31
Many thanks, Jono, for running such a good, entertaining competition, and for your excellent summation. The clips (particularly the Ulysses one) are interesting too. Well done KT17 on your win - it's a good clue. I'm delighted with my bronze.
56 of 65  -   Report This Post

mathprofrockstar

6th January 2021, 19:33
Congrats, KT17. Excellent clue. I was toying with a boomers clue myself (and no I don't mean boomer sooner.) Having already posted one too late clue, I threw in the towel. But thanks to Jono for reviewing my non-entry anyway, and for hosting, and above all, for the thorough summing up. I also enjoyed the clips, particularly the Ulysses one. I must actually finish that damn book one day.
57 of 65  -   Report This Post

mathprofrockstar

6th January 2021, 19:38
Also, there was a not too long ago Listener where Ulysses, or more precisely, the trial in the US over the publication was the theme. Did anybody here do that one? Quite an enjoyable puzzle.
58 of 65  -   Report This Post

jimmygtal

6th January 2021, 19:43
Well done kt17, and thanks to Jono for being such an excellent host. I hope people pick up Ulysses for a read. My daughter is in her first year at uni and one night I sent her a paragraph from Ulysses, can't remember the context, but she replied with 'Aha yep made me chuckle, can’t say I’ve read anything like that before!'
The genius of Joyce!
59 of 65  -   Report This Post

dorrien

6th January 2021, 19:59
Nicely done Jono

Congrats KT17. Quite an act for you to follow next week!
60 of 65  -   Report This Post