Will37, thanks for that - interesting stuff. Yes, it's impressive that Doc has been setting Spectator crosswords for so long. My gripe is inspired by sheer disappointment. Doc gave us excellent puzzles for many, many years and I used to look forward to seeing his name. About 18 months or so ago, he had a long run of Brewer's-related puzzles and many of them were quite poor. One week we'd have unclued entries that followed 'Green', say, then a few weeks later we'd have unclued entries that followed 'First'. There was a fair bit of discussion on the Forum, with many solvers feeling let down.