Hi Tony, Rossim and Mary6.
Thanks for your comments. Gosh, It's years since I read the Guardian and I haven't had a go at Philistine since I stopped downloading their free cryptics. I used enjoy them but found I was spending far too much time with my head down every day.
This is not the first time a "coincidence clue" has happened to me. I suppose it's bound to occur from time to time. Makes me feel a wee bit happy to find an occasional 'similar' clue in the quality crossword papers. Yippee!
Take great care everyone during the coming week. See you next Tuesday
Bless
John